LHC reserves verdict, scolds state counsel for ‘lack of knowledge’ on internet disruptions

LAHORE: The Lahore High Court (LHC) today scolded the state counsel for his non-seriousness and lack of knowledge on the matter of recent nationwide internet service disruptions.

LHC Justice Shakil Ahmad heard the petition, filed by a citizen named Noman Sarwar, seeking the immediate restoration of internet access across the country.

The disruption has troubled millions across the country accessing internet services due to limited connectivity. The internet slowdown has impacted major online platforms like Facebook and WhatsApp and freelancers.

After months of speculation about firewall installation, the federal IT Minister confirmed that the government is upgrading its ‘web management system’ to address cybersecurity threats.

The petitioner nominated the federal government, Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA), and other entities as respondents in the case. During the hearing today, the state prosecutor Rana Noman sought time from the court to present a detailed report on internet disruption after consultation with the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA).

Meanwhile, Justice Ahmad expressed dissatisfaction with the state counsel’s lack of preparedness. “This is a matter of public interest and your seriousness is such that you do not even have adequate information about this issue,” Justice Ahmad remarked.

Later, the LHC reserved its verdict, with the judge saying that the court would issue appropriate orders for the internet disruptions as a matter of public interest.

According to the petition, the internet and social media applications were shut down in the country without the authorities giving any notice or reason. “Businesses and every sphere of life are being affected because of the internet’s closure. Shutting down the internet is also a violation of fundamental rights,” the plea said.

According to the petition, the actions violated Articles 9 (security of person), 18 (freedom of trade, business or profession), 19 (freedom of speech, etc), 19A (right to information), and 25A (equality of citizens). It further urged the court to order the federal government to “ensure uninterrupted internet services throughout” the country.

Additionally, the Pakistan Software Houses Association (P@SHA) has warned that the country’s economy could lose up to $300 million due to the prolonged internet disruptions. Fiverr, an online marketplace, has made several Pakistani freelancers’ accounts ‘unavailable’.